To access exclusive videos from Catholic Unscripted please JOIN our channel / @catholicunscripted

In this conversation, Mark Lambert and Matt Gaspers delve into the contentious topic of whether a Pope can be considered a heretic. They explore the historical context provided by theologian Robert Bellarmine, who outlines five opinions regarding heretical popes. The discussion emphasizes the necessity of church hierarchy involvement in addressing heresy and the implications of papal infallibility as defined by Vatican I. The conversation concludes with a call for formal correction of the Pope's teachings, highlighting the ongoing relevance of these issues within the Catholic Church today.
takeaways
The Pope's actions can lead to debates about heresy.
Bellarmine's five opinions provide a framework for understanding papal authority.
The church hierarchy plays a crucial role in addressing heresy.
Papal infallibility does not mean the Pope is incapable of error.
Formal correction of the Pope is necessary for clarity in doctrine.
Historical precedents exist for addressing heretical popes.
The visible unity of the church is essential for faith.
The current papacy has raised significant theological questions.
The faithful must be aware of the implications of papal teachings.
Ongoing discussions about the Pope's role are vital for the church's future.